AI 人才市场的两极化
00:03:22–00:13:53Insight
- 前沿部署工程师需要技术深度,也要能与销售、客户和管理层共同落地。
- 工程、产品与设计边界收缩,产品判断、品味、好奇心和系统思考重新升值。
- 过度狭窄的专业角色与缺少场景经验的新人更容易受到工具能力挤压。
Lenny Rachitsky You have built and are known as someone that can build the most elite, high-talent density teams. Let's start with how people do it wrong. Something you call the funnel of doom.
Adam Ward Companies think about recruiting like a funnel. I am going to reach out to 100 people. 20% of those are all high. By definition, that is not the top 20%. That is just the 20 people who you caught on a bad day. The way we all recruit is we kind of weed people out at each stage and we hire the remainder. In your mind like, "Hey, there are 50 people in the world who can do this. Let's go find those 50 people." And you relentlessly pursue and you focus your energy on activating t
hose people, not trying to find them out of the funnel of doom.
The mistake that most companies make is they'll say, "Hey, Lenny, who's the best product engineer you know?" That is the worst question you can ask. The better question to ask is, "Hey, Lenny, of all the product engineers you've worked with, who stands out to you as the person who's most collaborative with designers or who can translate a framework into a product better than anyone you've ever seen?"
Lenny Rachitsky When you're looking for that first recruiting hire, is there anything you think is important to look for?
Adam Ward Recruiters are excellent at 90% to 110% capacity and are terrible outside of that. If they only have half a rec load, they kind of are useless, but they're kind of great at this edge of adrenaline rush, busy. You want to find those people.
Lenny Rachitsky What are some things you've learned about building incredible teams, keeping people working for you over the long term?
Adam Ward When you look at candidate satisfaction scores, the number one thing that's always there is...
Lenny Rachitsky Today, my guest is Adam Ward. Adam is known in the Valley as the most effective recruiting leader at building elite, high-talent density teams. He co-founded an independent recruiting firm called Growth by Design, which Cursor acquired fully last year, which is not something that you often hear and is a testament to how good he and his team are and how important talent is right now in today's market.
Adam is now head of talent at Cursor, helping them scale and build one of the most talent-dense teams in the world. Prior to starting his own firm, Adam led global recruiting at Pinterest, growing the company from 200 to over 2,000 employees. And before that, he led a global team of 65 recruiters across 10 offices at Facebook, helping them scale Facebook's tech org from 1,000 to over 10,000 employees.
If hiring the best people is your number one priority as it should be, this conversation will open your mind up to what it takes to do that. Adam gets super tactical and extremely specific, and you are going to thank me for inviting Adam on this podcast to share all of this incredible advice. A huge thank you to Bree Wolfson, Janet Fishberg, Jill Macri, Mike Joyner, and Tim Kendall for suggesting topics and questions for this conversation.
Before we get into it, don't forget to check out lennysproductpass.com for a free year of the hottest and most beautifully crafted AI products in the world available exclusively to Lenny's Newsletter subscribers. With that, I bring you Adam Ward. Adam, thank you so much for being here. Welcome to the podcast.
Adam Ward Thanks so much for having me. It's a pleasure.
Lenny Rachitsky You've been doing this for 20 years now, hiring, recruiting, building teams. How different is the market we're in today? How crazy is the market and the hiring market we're in today?
Adam Ward If there's a scale, it's an 11. But yeah, I do think there are similarities to some other markets we've been in over time. You mentioned the years. There was a moment in time where a lot of companies were moving to mobile and there literally was not a mobile engineer. An iOS engineer was not a thing, but there was a scramble for talent to build your mobile app and things like that.
There was this moment that was the thing and it has some similarities to that market and moment. I think that really the difference here is everything here is just so compressed. So that mobile moment was two years maybe where there was no mobile engineers and then they were like mobile bootcamp, mobile engineer bootcamps, all these things. And now we're in days, we're in weeks.
There are no months or year measures right now. And so what makes us feel very different.
Lenny Rachitsky The other thing that feels very different about this market is there's many people doing extremely well. It's the most competitive, as you said, 11 out of 10 for specific roles. A lot of other people are just really struggling, having a really hard time finding jobs.
Adam Ward Yeah, it's a tale of two cities, really. You can read back-to-back headlines of NBA salary offers to a new grad PhD, and the next line being a blue chip company laying off 10% of workforce. How can both of these things be true? And you see this shift of how companies are doing work and getting work done.
And I really believe we're in this moment where there's this resettlement of talent and labor and how work gets done. And I really believe that there will be a resettlement and there'll be a shift and this will come back. But I feel like we're in one of the largest gaps of those worlds right now that I believe will, and I want to believe will come back closer together.
Lenny Rachitsky This episode is brought to you by our season's presenting sponsor, WorkOS. What do OpenAI, Anthropic, Cursor, Replit, Sierra, Clay, and hundreds of other winning companies all have in common? They are all powered by WorkOS. If you're building a product for the enterprise, you felt the pain of integrating single sign-on, skim, RBAC, audit logs, and other features required by large companies.
WorkOS turns those deal blockers into drop-in APIs with a modern developer platform built specifically for B2B SaaS. Literally every startup that I'm an investor in that starts to expand upmarket ends up working with WorkOS, and that's because they are the best. Whether you are a seat stage startup trying to land your first enterprise customer or a unicorn expanding globally, WorkOS is the fastest path to becoming enterprise ready and unblocking growth. It's essentially Strip
e for enterprise features.
Visit workos.com to get started or just hit up their Slack where they have actual engineers waiting to answer your questions. WorkOS allows you to build faster with delightful APIs, comprehensive docs, and a smooth developer experience. Go to workos.com to make your app enterprise ready today. What are roles that are kind of trending up in the most in demand right now? And what are maybe less and less in demand?
And you have a really unique perspective because not only you're at Cursor now, but before that you had your own independent agency working with a ton of different companies. So you got to see across a lot of different places. What's kind of trending up? What's most in demand and what's maybe softer now?
Adam Ward Yeah, I think one thing that's really in demand is this, and there's lots of different names for it, but this forward-deployed engineer, this technical person who can partner with a sales team and partner with a customer to deploy what can be for some audiences in a company, a very technical and maybe overwhelming product or helping companies think about moving from token maxing to optimizing, maxing to optimizing.
And so that's I think a new skill as CFOs start to get the bill coming in. Companies are able to help partner with them to think about what's the best solution for them. So that's a really unique skill because you're deeply technical yourself, you understand the product, but you can also walk into a room with executives and leaders and help conjugate some of that and then even help them deploy that into their workforce. So I think that's a real supply demand issue right now.
I think maybe the thing that is waning, I would say, is the specialized technical person. The person who is... Because I think you almost see this squeezing together of engineer product design in some ways where we would love a designer who could actually be more of a design engineer. And we want that super deep technical engineer that has a little bit more stronger product sense.
So I think the people who are maybe very narrow, very deep and overly specialized in a way are waning in the same way along that vein might also be the new grad who just hasn't had enough experience to be able to do that, where a product like Cursor or others can do some of that work right now.
Lenny Rachitsky This is extremely interesting. I haven't heard it put this way before. Interestingly with the FDE role, it feels similar to the mobile example you shared where very few people have actually been forward-deployed engineers. So what's kind of the, I don't know, the look of a person that can become an FDE?
Adam Ward Yeah, I actually think it is that engineer. It is that person who maybe was a full stack engineer in three to five years ago, is now maybe actually that forward-deployed engineer. And you talk to some of these folks and they actually unlock something in them. They're kind of moving out of the terminal and moving in into the company and into the customers and clients.
And for the right person, that's super energizing, unlocks another chapter or maybe an unexpected chapter in their career.
Lenny Rachitsky That's interesting. I was expecting you to say AI researchers, so this is interesting. And imagine because there's not as many of those roles.
Adam Ward I think so. I think that's a very defined set. And so I feel like it's a very clear bracket of what that is and how many there are and where they are. And I think that sometimes the bigger challenges are the nebulous things or the very new things that I think are sometimes just as challenging as the scarcity ones of an AI or ML engineer.
Lenny Rachitsky Just as a final question along these lines, what about just the core product design engineering roles? Are those kind of steady as they've been? Is one increasing, decreasing? How's that looking?
Adam Ward I think they're hot. But I think you probably see a lot of conversation out there around this where I think we're getting a little bit back in a good way to the craft of things. And so if you think about what AI can do in the design world, it can also create a lot of slop in its own way. And so I'm an optimist. You'll probably hear that throughout.
Lenny Rachitsky Same.
Adam Ward I think it's just a better way to live. But I think what will hopefully help us get back is to the craft of what we do and maybe an appreciation for it. And I see that in the design world too.
Lenny Rachitsky And is that in saying ICs are more in demand and especially ICs that have good taste, good judgment? Is that kind of the-
Adam Ward I think so. Yeah. I think we've seen this for maybe the last 12 months, the rise of the power of IC. And the recognition and appreciation for that work, I think has come almost in a full circle moment for them. But I think taste, decision-making, problem solving, these characteristics, curiosity in all the good ways I think are coming back up to the surface.
Lenny Rachitsky Awesome. Okay. So let me zoom out and frame the conversation that I'm hoping we have broadly. You have built and are known as someone that can build the most elite, high-talent density teams. So many people kept telling me you are the person that does this better than anyone else. This is every company's and founder's dream, build the highest talent density team. So I'm going to go through this in a sequence.
Let's start with something you call the funnel of doom hiring. Talk about the funnel of doom. What is the funnel of doom?
Adam Ward Yeah. And this is a concept I got to recognize my very first as an intern actually in 1998 at a company called Trilogy, which is somewhat of an infamous company around recruiting and it's kind of where I learned to trade. My very first manager, Jeff Daniel, we did this campus tour around the country talking to CS students. And that's where I first heard the term and he coined that term. So I had to acknowledge that.
But I think what the funnel did forever, almost forever, as you think about the recruiting history, companies think about recruiting like a funnel, maybe akin to a sales funnel where they think about different stages, pass through rates and things like that. And when you think about how most companies have recruited over these last several decades, it's really been candidates come from three buckets. They apply, they are activated or sourced or they're referred.
But if you think about for a lot of companies who think about talent density, typically referrals and sourcing or activation of passive talent is really the focus. And when you even narrow further on this source talent, this is how most companies think about it. I am going to reach out to 100 people. 20 people will reply just for round numbers. So 20% of those will reply. By definition, that is not the top 20%.
That is just the 20 people who you caught on a bad day for them. Good day for you, bad day for them. And so you're starting with a suboptimal set. You're not starting with the top 20% even if that's what. And then the way we all recruit is we kind of weed people out at each stage and we hire the remainder. So this remainder hiring is the output of the funnel of doom. And when you say that out loud, you're like, that's kind of messed up.